Labels

Tuesday, November 25, 2025

Review: Black Forest Cake Murder (Sinclair Sisters Bakery Mystery #2) by Karen McSpade

Black Forest Cake Murder

Sinclair Sisters Bakery Mystery Series #2

by Karen McSpade

Published: November 25, 2025

Publisher: Newcastle Media

Genre: Mystery, Cozy Mystery, Mystery Romance, Murder Mystery, Amateur Sleuths, Suspense

 

Blurb:


Perfect for readers who love small-town cozy mysteries with complex family dynamics, hidden secrets, and unexpected twists.

Behind every delicious slice is a recipe for murder.

When a renowned food critic is found dead after visiting Sinclair’s Sweets, the beloved family bakery’s reputation crumbles…and so does the Sinclair family’s peace. For Holly, Noelle, and Joy Sinclair, it’s more than bad news — it’s personal. Their father becomes the prime suspect in a murder that threatens to tear their small Montana town apart.

Determined to clear his name, the three sisters must unravel a tangled web of secrets, bitter rivalries, and long-buried grudges simmering beneath the quaint streets of Chestnut Hills. As clues lead them down unexpected paths — from a jealous competitor’s simmering resentment to a mysterious stranger’s shadowy past — the clock ticks toward another deadly strike.

Amid the mounting suspense, Holly wrestles with her feelings for Chad, the local detective and her high school crush, while navigating the complicated presence of his determined ex. With family loyalty, romance, and a treasured bakery all on the line, will the Sinclair sisters rise to the challenge and solve the mystery before the killer serves their final course?

Perfect for fans of cozy mystery romance with heartwarming family dynamics and nail-biting suspense, Black Forest Cake Murder will keep you guessing until the very last crumb.

Pick up your copy and dive into this sweet yet deadly tale today.

Goodreads ~ Amazon ~ BookBub


My Review:

Black Forest Cake Murder is the second book in the Sinclair Sisters Bakery Mystery series by Karen McSpade. It is the first book I’ve read in the series, although I knew it; I didn’t even realize it when I was reading it.

I was drawn into the story from the beginning. I like the Sinclair Sisters, Holly, Noelle, and Joy, and I like that the story is told from all three sisters' points of view. Holly, Noelle, and Joy run a bakery with their father.

They are preparing for a food critic to visit their bakery. The food critic seemed to be somewhere else during the review, which made her seem like she might not be a decent person. However, I believe she was preoccupied with troubling thoughts.

Later, the food critic is found dead in an alley. The Sinclair sisters’ dad becomes the prime suspect in the case, as he didn’t have an alibi. The sisters set out to prove their father’s innocence, as they knew their dad did not kill that woman.

I enjoyed getting to know the sisters and hearing about their lives. The mystery and suspense kept me on the edge of my seat. I wanted to know what was happening, who killed the food critic, and why.

I can’t wait to see what happens after Black Forest Cake Murder. I look forward to the next book in the Sinclair Sisters Bakery Mystery series. I wonder what awaits the Sinclair Sisters!

Not only that, but I highly recommend Black Forest Cake Murder to all murder mystery fans! Grab a copy of Black Forest Cake Murder today!


Connect with Karen McSpade

Goodreads ~ Amazon ~ BookBub

Facebook ~ Instagram ~ TikTok

0 comments: