Life of Pie...Cut Short
A Penelope Sinclair Cozy Murder Mystery #5
by Tessa Aura
Published: November 14, 2025
Genre: Mystery, Suspense, Cozy Mystery, Amateur Sleuth, Animal Mystery
Blurb:
At Bath’s Harvest Festival, one pie is to die for…literally.
Just when I thought life in Bath might finally settle down, Grandma Joyce shows up—suitcase in one hand, apple pie in the other. But when the festival’s judge keels over after a single bite, all fingers point straight at her.
With her initials stamped on the poisoned pie tin—and my own reputation on the line—Teo and I have to sniff out the truth fast.
Hank, the debt-ridden Harvest King, hides more secrets than hay bales. Nadine Fletcher, a rival baker with a failing shop, bristles with motive. And Vera Montgomery, Bath’s reigning pie queen, will guard her crown at any cost.
My Review:
Penelope's Grandma Joyce makes an unexpected entrance into town, anticipating that everyone will be charmed by her in no time. Upon hearing about the local Harvest Festival pie baking competition, Grandma, a skilled baker herself, decides to participate.
At the pie contest, Grandma certainly has everyone captivated until one of the judges suddenly collapses after tasting her pie. This turn of events leads to Grandma becoming the prime suspect. Penelope is convinced of her grandmother's innocence and begins to wonder if someone is trying to set her up, or if Grandma just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.
As Penelope digs deeper, she uncovers that the judge was not who he claimed to be. What is going on here? A phony judge? Where is the real judge? Is he alive, or has something happened to him? Why is this individual pretending to be someone else? Was there a motive to harm him, or was the actual judge the intended target?
Life of Pie...Cut Short immerses me in its narrative from the instant the judge takes his first bite of Grandma’s pie. It kept me engaged with its unexpected developments. The numerous twists left me astonished and filled with questions.
In my view, Life of Pie...Cut Short might just be the finest installment I've encountered in the Penelope Sinclair Cozy Murder Mystery series to date. Don't misunderstand me; I've enjoyed every book written by Tessa Aura, but the multitude of twists in this one has truly captivated me.
I eagerly anticipate the next book in the Penelope Sinclair Cozy Murder Mystery series to discover what lies ahead for Penelope and Teo. And I certainly hope Grandma Joyce remains a part of the story for some time.
I wholeheartedly recommend Life of Pie...Cut Short to all fans of mysteries! Be sure to pick up your copy of Life of Pie...Cut Short today!
Check out all the books in the Penelope Sinclair Cozy Murder Mystery series I’ve read.
Shop 'til you Drop Dead #1
Dead Man's Hand #2
Signed, Sealed and Stabbed #3
Scooped, there it is...Dead #4
Life of Pie...Cut Short #5




































